Blood Pressure Meds Evidence Allowed in Calif. Suit

Blood Pressure Meds Evidence Allowed in Calif. Suit

News Nov 06, 2012

Nov. 06--Whether a doctor who suffered a stroke resulting in permanent brain damage was taking his blood pressure medication will be admissible as evidence in his family's civil suit against the city and Hall Ambulance, a judge decided Monday.

"In order to understand what medical condition was being exacerbated, we have to know what the condition was," Judge J. Eric Bradshaw said during a hearing on pre-trial motions that continues today.

In 2007, Dr. Mohamad Harb suffered a stroke and was allegedly denied immediate transport to a hospital emergency room because police thought he was drunk. In 2008, his family sued the city of Bakersfield, the Bakersfield Police Department, Hall Ambulance, former police officer Claudia Payne and some Hall Ambulance employees.

On Monday, the civil trial started with a pretrial hearing in which Bradshaw granted and denied several motions from the plaintiff and defense attorneys. Among them, Bradshaw decided evidence about Harb's blood pressure medication will be allowed. He also decided information about a sheriff's investigation into Payne will not be admissable.

Attorneys for the city and ambulance company alleged Harb was not taking his blood pressure medication, which caused a severe stroke that would have resulted in brain damage regardless of how soon he arrived at the hospital.

It is relevant for the jury to know about Harb's history with his medication in order to understand the nature and severity of the stroke, argued Mick Marderosian, attorney with Marderosian, Runyon, Cercone and Lehman Attorneys at Law representing the city.

Bradshaw agreed. "I don't know how the jury can decide if something was made worse if they don't know how it started," he said.

But Harb's attorneys said the issue at hand is not what caused the stroke. The issue is whether he was given the proper care once it occurred.

Thomas Brill, attorney with the Law Offices of Young and Nichols representing Harb, compared the situation to a football player who gets a concussion while playing. If a doctor fails to diagnose the concussion once the player is in the hospital, it is irrelevant that the injury was suffered while playing football, no matter how dangerous of an activity that is, he said.

Furthermore, Brill said, Harb's blood pressure at the scene of the stroke was only slightly elevated. Before that, Harb only had two other instances of high blood pressure, Brill said.

Continue Reading

"They're bringing this in to try to prejudice the case and make him look like a bad guy," Brill said.

Also at issue was whether a case involving Payne being investigated in connection with a false police report would be admissable. Bradshaw declared that the information would be off limits during the trial.

In 2006, Payne reported stolen a horse she had been taking care of for a friend. A few years passed and the owner of the horse found it in possession of a third party. When detectives called Payne, she admitted she sold it to pay for breeding costs and then filed a false police report.

The case was investigated by the Kern County Sheriff's Office and forwarded to the District Attorney's office recommending charges. The DA's office chose not to file charges, citing a lapsed statute of limitations.

Jim Braze, attorney with Borton Petrini, LLP, representing Hall Ambulance, said the case should be included as evidence because it calls into question Payne's credibility as a witness.

Marderosian said he was offended that it was on the table as evidence and that including it would be trial by character assassination.

"This was not a felony conviction. It didn't even rise to the level of filing a complaint," he said.

Bradshaw will continue to hear motions from the attorneys Tuesday, including on whether Hall Ambulance owner and Bakersfield Mayor Harvey Hall can be compelled to testify.

Jury selection will begin Wednesday. The trial is expected to last into the second week of December.

loading next article...

Copyright 2012 - The Bakersfield Californian

The Bakersfield Californian
Rebecca Kheel
A leading healthcare Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) and data provider taps a marketing veteran to support Its rapid growth.
The girl happened to crash into the back of an FDNY ambulance, whose crew members got out and helped her stop the car and revived her father with Narcan.
The 25-year-old woman was found overdosing in her bathroom along with her young son, who needed several doses of Narcan to become responsive and was later discovered to have fentanyl and methamphetamine in his system.
The QuikLitter Lite is designed to be lightweight and compact so multiple litters can be carried simultaneously to a scene.
The highly skilled team members practiced drills inside a local school in preparation for a possible active shooter situation.
Any first responders who are permanently disabled due to injuries that occurred in the line of duty are eligible for a property tax exemption following an amendment to the state's constitution passed last year.
Pulsara has been selected as one of the finalist's in Fierce Innovation Awards for its product Prehospital Alerting Package, an app that allows EMS providers to send patient information to the emergency department en route to the hospital for patient care optimization.
The Office of Homeland Security and Emergency Management conducted an exercise for the county's Emergency Operations Center's protocol for recovery efforts following a category 4 hurricane.
Avaya plans to honor the Texas Commission as it sees the adoption of Kari’s Law build across the country, a law which would mandate any company or organization with multi-line telephone systems to provide direct-dial access to 9-1-1.
The company achieves a milestone of its first U.S. regulatory filing for a medical device which would aid in hemostasis and wound care.
Senators will have to vote on multiple amendments on the health care repeal bill.
County commissioners decided to write off over $5 million in uncollectible ambulance bills owed by residents, an amount that has been building since the 1940s.
The amount of deaths caused by substance abuse and mental health issues in the first half of 2017 have surpassed the total deaths of 2016.

The raging wildfires have forced 10,000 residents to evacuate their homes. 

For the first time in my EMS career, I froze.