Witness Says Calif. Paramedic 'Abandoned' Patient

Witness Says Calif. Paramedic 'Abandoned' Patient

News Nov 29, 2012

Nov. 29--An expert witness in a $25 million lawsuit against the city of Bakersfield and Hall Ambulance testified Wednesday that a Hall paramedic committed "abandonment of a patient" in 2007 when he left stroke victim Dr. Mohamad Harb in the custody of police rather than immediately taking Harb to a local hospital.

Ted Blankenheim, a career paramedic and registered nurse from Redding who has extensive experience in emergency medical training and reviews, told the jury that the actions of Hall paramedic Brian Dumont -- a co-defendant in the ongoing civil trial -- represented "a gross departure from the standards of medical care."

According to Blankenheim, all paramedics must be well-versed and well-trained in state law, which ultimately gives authority over patient care to the top-ranking medical personnel at an accident scene.

"It's not OK to leave," Blankenheim told the jury. Especially not when you're treating a 57-year-old exhibiting a "mentally altered" state of confusion and bizarre behavior.

Even if police are resistant to releasing the patient into the care of emergency workers -- as Dumont testified earlier in the trial -- Dumont should have insisted, or asked for assistance from higher authorities, such as the on-duty ER doctor at the hospital, a watch commander at the police department or another authority.

But Jim Braze, the attorney representing Hall and Dumont; and Mick Marderosian, representing the city and former Bakersfield police officer Claudia Payne, worked to poke holes in Blankenheim's testimony. (Witnesses for the defense won't be called until plaintiff attorneys Thomas Brill and Steve Nichols have rested their case.)

In his earlier testimony, Dumont said he has always operated on the assumption that the person at the scene "with a badge and a gun" has ultimate authority. And he testified that Payne insisted that she would transport Harb in her patrol car, and that Dumont needed to move his ambulance because it was blocking her exit.

But there appears to be a clear dispute about the facts between his version of the incident and Payne's, who apparently testified in a deposition that Dumont indicated Harb's vital signs were normal and that he didn't need to be transported via ambulance.

Marderosian said the evidence will show that Payne's actions that day were those of a competent law enforcement officer.

Additional evidence has also come to light showing that Harb had suffered a prior stroke, that he wasn't taking his blood pressure medication against the advice of his personal physician and, according to lawyer Marderosian, that the nature of the hemorrhagic stroke in 2007 was so severe that the damage to Harb's brain was inevitable, even if his care was delayed.

Continue Reading

Adding to the complexity of the lawsuit is the fact that the interests of the two main defendants, Hall Ambulance and the city, sometimes are at odds.

Dumont was at the scene for just 10 minutes, Braze said earlier in the trial. "That's the entire case against Hall Ambulance: that 10 minutes."

The incident that would transform the lives of Harb and his family -- and lead to their ongoing legal battle -- occurred in November 2007 as Harb, still wearing surgical scrubs, was driving his Mercedes after leaving a 12-hour shift at Kern Medical Center.

As he headed west on 24th Street, Harb's car came to rest at the right side of the roadway, near Oak Street, flattening a tire against the curb.

Payne arrived at the scene minutes later, where she saw that Harb had urinated on the sidewalk and vomited on his shirt.

He was given two alcohol breath tests, both of which registered zero, according to Dumont's written report -- although there appears to be disagreement about that as well.

Medical tests later showed Harb had suffered a life-threatening stroke, yet the first Hall Ambulance crew called to the scene, headed by Dumont, departed without him, according to the company's own reports, leaving Harb sitting on the curb, one shoe off and lying in the gutter.

Apparently believing the disoriented man was under the influence of alcohol or drugs, police handcuffed him behind his back and sat him down on a curb for several minutes -- precious minutes that Blankenheim, the witness from Redding, testified are crucial in responding to stroke symptoms.

"Time is brain," is the cardinal rule for dealing with stroke victims, he testified.

The trial is expected to continue well into December.

loading next article...

Copyright 2012 - The Bakersfield Californian

The Bakersfield Californian
Steven Mayer
NHTSA's new video follows EMS data from its collection through its use to improve future care.
First Priority Global, one of the country's leading suppliers of public safety, emergency response and clean transportation solutions, announces the opening of a new facility in Flanders, NJ.
Christopher Wimmer was sentenced to jail time and probation for taking photos with 41 unconscious patients in a selfie competition he was in with another paramedic.
Students say the mock DUI accident was a very realistic learning experience, especially when firefighters, EMTs and police arrived at the scene.
The Columbia County EMS provider oversees emergency efforts from Lake City EOC during the latest storm.
EMTs, firefighters and police officers dealt with a car accident causing the release of sulfur dioxide and an active shooter in a hospital.
Search and rescue teams from all over the world traveled to Mexico City to help find survivors trapped in the rubble since Tuesday's 7.1 magnitude earthquake.
Residents who register with the program provide important details about health conditions and even bedroom locations so rescue workers spend less time searching for victims.
As soon as a runway can be cleared for their arrival, the 27-member Task Force 1 FEMA Urban Response Team is ready to take off for search and rescue efforts in the wake of Hurricane Maria's destruction of Puerto Rico.
The Pennsylvania Department of Health and Pennsylvania Emergency Health Services Council today recognized first responders for their commitment and dedication to delivering quality medical-care in the field during emergency situations.
Dr. Vincent Duron from the Columbia University Medical Center in New York received a $100,000 research grant to enhance standard pediatric trauma care.
The award-winning video features a series of stunning training courses driven by groundbreaking video demonstrations of the most commonly encountered fire ground evolutions.

A  7.1-magnitude earthquake on Tuesday leveled buildings, homes, and government centers across the city. At one partially flattened school, the hunt for dozens of missing children captivated the nation.

At least nine people have died, structural damage is extensive, and flooding coupled with 155mph winds has left the entire island without power.
The Volunteer First Responder Housing Act aims to recruit and retain volunteers in the community by providing discounts on house prices to eligible citizens.