Calif. Agencies Argue over Who Rescued Hikers

Calif. Agencies Argue over Who Rescued Hikers

News Dec 01, 2012

ALTADENA, Calif. - There's a tale associated with the Eaton Canyon rescue of two injured hikers.

And, like most stories, the details depend upon who is writing the history.

In a Sheriff's Department press released issued late Monday night, deputies reported that the L.A. County Fire Department put two injured hikers on a helicopter and flew them to safety after the pair were saved by the sheriff's Altadena Search and Rescue team.

On Tuesday morning, the Pasadena Fire Department gave a differing version of events. Officials said city firefighters carried the injured hikers from the falls, and Pasadena paramedics drove them to Huntington Memorial Hospital.

When media outlets began reporting the sheriff's version of events, it set off a flurry of emails within the Pasadena Fire Department seeking to correct things.

"This is not right," Pasadena Fire Capt. Robert Taylor wrote to spokeswoman Lisa Derderian. "(County Fire) would not fly (patient) out. Too much risk for gain in their words.

This is not the first time (Pasadena) got no recognition for (a) difficult rescue," Taylor concluded.

Sheriff's Spokesman Steve Whitmore said the department won't get into a "he said, she said" battle with a smaller agency.

"We send out press releases when our people do outstanding jobs," Whitmore said. "Here is what's important: The people got saved."

So what did happen?

Continue Reading

The incident began with a 5:45 p.m. 911 call Monday that alerted authorities to two injured hikers near Eaton Canyon Falls. The spot is near where several other accidents and fatalities have occurred.

The hikers, both women, fell from the edge of the waterfall and slammed onto the rocks 20 feet below, Derderian said.

Because the incident occurred after dark, L.A. County Fire officials declined to use its helicopter to effect a rescue, Pasadena officials said.

Instead, rescue personnel from the Pasadena Fire Department, L.A. County Fire and Altadena Search and Rescue - an all-volunteer force - hiked into Eaton Canyon.

Upon their arrival at the scene, Pasadena firefighters determined that one woman was in critical condition, while the second suffered only minor injuries, Derderian said.

Eaton Canyon is partially within Pasadena city limits and parts of the well-traveled trail are in unincorporated Los Angeles County, placing it under purview of both county and city emergency personnel. Rescue efforts are joint operations, said Derderian, and credit is due to all of those who save the lives of distressed hikers in the canyon.

Ranking Pasadena officials say they are tired of mix-ups resulting from Sheriff's Department press releases. Officials said those releases often mislead the public as to who conducts forest rescues.

"In the past, they have taken credit and made it look like they single-handedly done stuff," Derderian said. "I usually just let it go."

In an email to Derderian, Taylor also implied that competition for limited government funding may lie at the root of the snafu.

"I know all agencies are fighting to keep their programs but the LACOSD public information is borderline egregious considering the amount of misinformation contained," Taylor wrote.

Copyright 2012 Tower Media, Inc.All Rights Reserved

The Daily News of Los Angeles
NIOSH and NHTSA offer a new fact sheet based on recent research.

Members of Miami-Dade Fire Rescue, City of Miami Fire Rescue, and Florida Urban Search and Rescue teams finally returned home to their families after days of working hard to help residents in the Florida Keys devastated by Hurricane Irma.

Mississippi Task Force 1 deployed to Florida to rescue residents from their flooded homes.
The driver ran through a crowd of people after losing control of his vehicle, seriously injuring 11 people, several of whom were children.
The bills will provide more privacy for car accident victims who are bombarded by medical and legal offices pushing their services.
Among one of the first in the state deemed a "Cardiac Ready Community," Mayville, N.D. has increased the number of AEDs in the area and more residents are taking CPR classes.
The 9/11 Never Forget Mobile Exhibit was featured at the 134th annual Connecticut State Firefighters Association Convention.
Redivus Health was recognized with Honorable Mention in the Health category of the Innovation by Design Awards.
The 2018 SIMLAB® Catalog is now available from Nasco Healthcare.
Joseph L. Comstock confessed that he began tampering with ambulance morphine and fentanyl supplies in 2014 after getting a tonsillectomy.
Caleb Sharpe, a student at Freeman High School, shot one student dead with a semi-automatic rifle and injured three other students until a custodian tackled and disarmed him.
The west coast has seen multiple extreme wildfires this season due to this year's historic drought.
The dangerous combination of water and electrical issues caused by the storm has nearly doubled the amount of structure fires the department responds to on average.

An explosion at the London Tube Station has left 22 people injured and is being treated as a terrorist incident.

For more on this story, click here.

Three members of the Hamilton County Emergency Medical Service, part of the five Tennessee ambulance strike teams, deployed to Florida in the wake of the destructive storm Irma, returned today having completed their six day mission.