SCOTUS: Non-Members Need Not Pay Public Unions

SCOTUS: Non-Members Need Not Pay Public Unions

Article Jun 27, 2018

A landmark Supreme Court ruling Wednesday that government employees don’t have to pay union fees if they’re not union members could have big implications for the fire service.

In the Illinois case Janus v. AFSCME Council 31, the court ruled 5-4 that such workers’ First Amendment rights protect them from being forced to contribute unless they actually join the union. Such fees are based on the idea that the union negotiates benefits for all members of groups like firefighters, not just those who have joined it, and thus represents everyone in the field. “States and public-sector unions may no longer extract agency fees from nonconsenting employees,” Justice Samuel Alito wrote in his majority opinion. 

The decision means public-sector unions, traditionally supporters of liberal candidates and causes, could face losses of income, membership, and influence—“a big loss for the coffers of the Democrats,” tweeted President Donald Trump. It overturns a precedent set in the 1977 case of Abood v. Detroit Board of Education, where justices ruled the unions could collect “fair share” or “agency fees” because they effectively represent all workers, members or not. 

International Association of Fire Fighters General President Harold Schaitberger condemned the ruling in a statement Wednesday morning. 

“The Janus vs. AFSCME Council 31 case was pushed by forces that want to take away the voices of firefighters and the power of all public employee unions,” Schaitberger said. “The intent is to handicap unions in our ability to improve members’ lives and to weaken the political power of public employees. We know the potential negative impacts that could come from the Supreme Court’s decision in Janus; however we are ready to take the best punch and deliver some blows ourselves to those that want to see firefighters and their unions weakened.”

The IAFF represents more than 85% of all professional firefighters and paramedics in the U.S. For more, see its website


Firefighters, EMTs, police officers and military members will receive a 25% discount on all sleep products.
Coming in September, the stamp depicts a firefighter, EMS provider, and police officer.
The program helps military personnel explore career options as they transition back into civilian life.
Chief John Whiting underwent reconstructive surgery after being attacked by one of the resident's dogs.
Joyce Craig, who died in 2014, was Philadelphia's first fallen female firefighter.
Ryan Cumbie, 22, and Troy Breton, 55, were en route to a call when they crashed with another vehicle.
Webb City EMS, police and fire department members were given medals for reviving a man who crashed into a house after suffering from a heart attack.
A former police officer and ten volunteer firefighters have been arrested for setting 13 fires over a two-year period.
The crew came across a vehicle collision while returning to their deployment center and quickly worked to extricate the driver.
A security vendor crunches the data to determine a top 100. 
The two organizations have streamlined the recertification process with a new web functionality.
NREMT and CAPCE have partnered to allow EMS providers to import CAPCE-approved courses directly into their National Registry accounts.
A study will be conducted to determine if a string of cancer diagnoses among Seattle's Station 31 members is linked to the carcinogens in the building.
Spokane Fire District 10 scheduled all 12 women from the staff of 80 firefighters to work the same shift together.
Panama City Beach's new fire station needs a crew, and the department is willing to hire EMS professionals with no fire training.