Women Less Likely to Receive CPR from Bystanders, Study Shows

Women Less Likely to Receive CPR from Bystanders, Study Shows

News Nov 13, 2017

Women are less likely than men to receive bystander CPR in public and far more likely to die afterward, according to a new study.

Researchers analyzed 19,331 cardiac events that occurred between 2011 and 2015 and released their preliminary results Saturday at American Heart Association’s Scientific Sessions.

“CPR involves pushing on the chest so that could make people less certain whether they can or should do CPR in public on women,” said Audrey Blewer, M.P.H., the study’s lead author and assistant director for educational programs at the Center for Resuscitation Science at the University of Pennsylvania in Philadelphia.

The data for the study was compiled by the Resuscitation Outcomes Consortium, a network of regional clinical centers in the United States and Canada that study out-of-hospital treatments of cardiac arrest and trauma.

The preliminary results they released showed 45 percent of men received bystander CPR in public settings compared to just 39 percent of women. By the time men were discharged from the hospital, their odds of survival were 23 percent greater compared to women.

The disparity narrowed to 35 percent of women and 36 percent of men receiving CPR when the emergencies occurred at home. There was no significant statistical difference.

“Ultimately this highlights a key knowledge gap in resuscitation science, that we need to characterize the bystander to better understand the barriers and biases to CPR delivery. From there this can help inform public messaging and public CPR training,” said Blewer.

Disparities for men and women exist throughout healthcare, experts say.

“Studies have shown that gender disparities exist in cardiovascular disease, as well as response to time-sensitive conditions. To our knowledge, no study has examined whether gender variation exists with receipt of layperson bystander CPR,” Blewer said.

According to a study released last year, women are less likely to receive several different potentially life-saving procedures after cardiac arrest. That research showed women were less likely to receive coronary angiography, which can be used to look for blocked arteries; angioplasty, which is the repair or unblocking of an artery; or to have their body temperature lowered to increase the chance of survival reduce the risk of brain damage.

Continue Reading

Some of the problems begin early in the process. While heart disease is the No. 1 killer of women, only one-third of all heart research subjects are women even though genders exhibit different symptoms and reactions to medications, treatments and medical devices.

“As long as women are underrepresented in clinical trials, we will continue to lack data to make accurate clinical decisions on 51 percent of the world’s population,” said authors in a specialized women’s issue of Circulation: Cardiovascular Quality and Outcomes in 2016 that drew attention to the issue.

This year's hasn't been very effective, particularly against the dangerous H3N2 strain.
Austin company Invisible Fence is donating 42 specialized kits for 'Love Your Pet Day.'
Maisaa Al Zoubi launched the program after a falling school door killed a 12-year-old.
Volusia County Deputy Michael Stoltz found the man with a roadside choke hold on the EMS provider.
Ohio's First Responder Face-Off is a benefit game between area police and firefighters.
Jason Dickey, remembered as a dedicated family man, died in a structure collapse while fighting a fire.
Fire Lt. Richard Jenks, 72, is remembered as a man with "the biggest heart."
Continuum® Earth provides a navigable map for public safety agencies to view live camera feeds, unit location, public transit, incidents and more during events.
A reorganization of the WTC Health Program for first responders affected by the toxins at Ground Zero could negatively impact their healthcare.
Sonoma County dispatchers were understaffed and had not been trained in coaching citizens trapped by the wildfires that killed 24 people.
The San Antonio Fire Department has released its position statement on the management of patients with potential spinal injuries.
If passed, the bill will allow medical professionals with firearms training to carry weapons when responding to an event with a SWAT team.
NENA members met with policymakers to discuss major improvements for the 9-1-1 system.
The 2018 ESO EMS index highlights areas of improvement such as documenting stroke assessment, 12-lead EKG use, and aspirin administration.
When a rescuer turns 50, his colleagues plot a birthday surprise.